IRA calculator

Compare a deductible traditional IRA with an after-tax Roth contribution using the same budget.

Traditional IRA after withdrawal tax
$506,154

Compared at age 65 with the same pre-tax contribution budget.

Breakdown & share
Traditional before tax
$617,261.05
Comparable Roth after tax
$504,207.85
Traditional contributions
$195,000.00
After-tax traditional in today’s dollars
$241,305.25
Estimates only.

Your inputs

yr

Example values. Change any of them.

yr
$
$
%
%
%
More options
%

What-if compare

Change a second scenario and see the results side by side.

Traditional after tax

Age 35Age 50Age 65
Traditional after taxRoth after tax
View numbers
PointTraditional after taxRoth after tax
Age 35$14,760.00$18,000.00
Age 36$20,975.60$24,150.00
Age 37$27,564.14$30,669.00
Age 38$34,547.98$37,579.14
Age 39$41,950.86$44,903.89
Age 40$49,797.92$52,668.12
Age 41$58,115.79$60,898.21
Age 42$66,932.74$69,622.10
Age 43$76,278.70$78,869.43
Age 44$86,185.42$88,671.59
Age 45$96,686.55$99,061.89
Age 46$107,817.74$110,075.60
Age 47$119,616.81$121,750.14
Age 48$132,123.81$134,125.15
Age 49$145,381.24$147,242.66
Age 50$159,434.12$161,147.21
Age 51$174,330.17$175,886.05
Age 52$190,119.98$191,509.21
Age 53$206,857.17$208,069.76
Age 54$224,598.60$225,623.95
Age 55$243,404.52$244,231.39
Age 56$263,338.79$263,955.27
Age 57$284,469.12$284,862.59
Age 58$306,867.27$307,024.34
Age 59$330,609.30$330,515.80
Age 60$355,775.86$355,416.75
Age 61$382,452.41$381,811.75
Age 62$410,729.56$409,790.46
Age 63$440,703.33$439,447.89
Age 64$472,475.53$470,884.76
Age 65$506,154.06$504,207.85

How it’s worked out

See how we got $506,154.06

Traditional after-tax value = traditional balance × (1 − withdrawal tax rate). Roth contribution budget = deductible traditional deposit × (1 − current tax rate).

  1. Project both accounts with the same return and age assumptions.
  2. The traditional scenario subtracts 18% at withdrawal. The Roth scenario reduces deposits by 22%.

About this calculator

The Roth comparison assumes eligible qualified withdrawals. The traditional projection assumes a fully deductible contribution and tax on full withdrawal at the rate you enter. The same starting balance is applied to both account types for comparison. SEP and SIMPLE plan limits differ.

Worked example

Traditional IRA after withdrawal tax · $506,154.06

Traditional after-tax value = traditional balance × (1 − withdrawal tax rate). Roth contribution budget = deductible traditional deposit × (1 − current tax rate).

  1. Project both accounts with the same return and age assumptions.
  2. The traditional scenario subtracts 18% at withdrawal. The Roth scenario reduces deposits by 22%.

Formula sources

Reference checked November 22, 2026 · Data as of 2026 policy inputs. Credentialed review pending.